Accessories

USG vs EdgeRouter|Which One Would You Choose This Time?

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

Did you get yourself a new home internet network under budget? But wait! How will you choose the router, if you got a tie between USG vs EdgeRouter?

We don’t expect this to be an easy decision, but there are a lot of features, you can look into before picking out a final choice. Let’s have a look! 

Considering USG, there are only two real advantages. First of all, they work great when you have an internet connection below 100 Mbit/s.

Secondly, they stand equipped with site-to-site VPN as well as Intrusion Prevention System (IPS). 

What about a faster CPU? EdgeRouter has a clear win here.

Therefore, it is a better choice if you need features such as Deep Packet Inspection and Queue Shaping or Firewall rules. 

Where USG will let you stay with the Unifi line, the EdgeRouter is cheaper and faster. In contrast, USG runs slower, whereas EdgeRouter is typically difficult to configure. 

Moreover, EdgeRouters can handle internet connections up to 1 Gbit/s with a price typically less than $50. 

We are hoping this detailed comparison will help you choose between USG vs EdgeRouter (Ubiquiti Unifi Security Gateway vs Ubiquiti Networks Networks Router.)

We will jump into the technical difference, advantages, disadvantages, and specifications of the two devices to let you pick out a far better choice for yourself.

USG vs EdgeRouter – Comparative Assessment  

Ubiquiti is famous for manufacturing networking products. These include routers for spectrum, wireless gadgets, etc. The recent models are now capable of serving broad range connectivity.

Therefore, they have been an ideal option not only for home networks but also for the large-sized Enterprise environments. 

Ubiquiti uses the network effect of social connection as part of its business pattern. This is dubious among hardware companies founded in the generation before social networking was even a thing

Ubiquiti uses the network effect of social connection as part of its business pattern. This is dubious among hardware companies founded in the generation before social networking was even a thing

The comparison between Ubiquiti USG vs EdgeRouter is aimed at attracting the audience from a similar market.

Sale
Ubiquiti Unifi Security Gateway (USG)Something Great
  • 3 Gigabit Ethernet ports, CLI management for advanced users

Ubiquiti Networks EdgeRouter X, 4-port...Something Great
  • Powered by 24V passive PoE or a power adapter, the EdgeRouter X features a passive PoE passthrough option to power an airMAX device.

In particular, this is the reason these two have been very often compared amongst users from domestic and professional fields.

So, this article will describe the two models, Ubiquiti USG and Ubiquiti Networks EdgeRouter X by diving deep into the details of each device. Let’s Go!

1. Ubiquiti Unifi Security Gateway (USG)

Specs

Brand Name: Ubiquiti Networks | Model Number: USG | Wireless Type: 802.11.b | Weight: 12.3 ounces | Dimensions: 1 x 1 x 1 inches | Voltage: 240 Volts |

Pros
  • 3 Gigabit Ethernet ports
  • Integrated with Unifi controller
  • Secure off-site management
  • 3 Gbps total line rate
  • One million packets/s for 64-byte packets
Cons
  • Rare customer support
Ubiquiti Unifi Security Gateway
Intrusion Prevention/Detection Systems

IPS and IDS help you keep an eye on the content of the traffic and identify any cyber threats or attacks.
Check Price from Amazon

Ubiquiti Unifi Security Gateway Review

USG is an excellent choice if you have other Unifi devices in your network. In case you are planning to buy other products in the Unifi series then it is best to consider USG. 

Why so?

Important: The USG can be coupled or integrated with the rest of the network to manage everything easily with a single Unifi Controller software.

In other words, it is an excellent replacement for a consumer router in a small office or home environment because the USG model is easier to manage and configure.

Not only just it provides much more speed but also is meant for regular consumer usage when compared throughout with other routers.

Features of Ubiquiti Unifi Security Gateway

Hardware Specifications 

  • The specifications for CPU and RAM are too good for the small device. However, the performance might be affected by enabling IPS and IDS. 

  • The speed throughput for Ubiquiti USG is quite impressive. It offers 1 Million PPS and a line rate of 3 Gbps with larger packets.

  • This means the device can easily handle the traffic demands of a small to medium network. 

Unifi Controller Management Software

  • All the Unifi devices can easily be configured and managed using Unifi Controller Management Software.

  • This provides a centralized management platform that is typical of both USG and EdgeRouter X. 

  • When it comes to USG, the management options include off-site and on-site management with the Unifi Cloud Controller and an Unifi Cloud Key. 

  • The option of Cloud Key stands out because it is a Linux PC controlling the Unifi software. Thus basically a hybrid management approach for cloud and local access.

EdgeOS Software For Improved Performance

  • Vyatta’s OS has now forked to introduce the EdgeOS that is powering both USG and EdgeRouter devices. 

  • Analogous to making permanent changes to the configuration of USG, you need to access the controller filesystem and introduce the required alterations in the JSON file.

  • This would allow for custom changes that are not possible using the GUI interface. 

Advanced Security Features 

  • When it comes to how “safe” the network is, USG offers everything that EdgeRouter is capable of but it has something extra in stock for you too. 

  • USG supports IPS and IDS. This feature helps to keep an eye on the content of the traffic and identify any cyber-attacks or threats.

  • To top it up, the site-to-site VPN offered by USG is easier to configure and the GUI as compared to EdgeRouter.

Convenient VLAN Support 

  • USG is the ultimate solution to traffic management problems.

  • The Unifi Security Gateway offers you a chance to create virtual network segments for enhanced security as well as better management of network traffic.

2. Ubiquiti Networks EdgeRouter (ER)
EdgeRouter x

Specs

Brand Name: Ubiquiti Networks | Model Number: ER-X | Wireless Type: N/A | Weight: 6.2 ounces | Dimensions: 7.4 x 3.6 x 0.87 inches | Voltage: 12 Volts |

Pros
  • Complete control over Firewall and QoS
  • Advanced Gigabit Ethernet Features
  • Advanced Security and Management
  • Sophisticated Routing Features
Cons
  • Gets heated quickly
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter
Automatic Topology Overview

Have a look at your whole network in a single go! Zoom out for the topology view for all the Ubiquiti devices.
Check Price from Amazon

Ubiquiti Networks EdgeRouter Review

Ubiquiti Networks has yet again amused its users by launching the EdgeRouter as part of the EdgeMAX platform. 

What is so special here?

To begin with, the EdgeRouter combines the excellent price to performance value with first-class reliability.

This device is an upgrade when you consider the advanced security features, ease of monitoring and management as well as sophisticated routing features. 

Important: This device is an upgrade when you consider the advanced security features, ease of monitoring and management as well as sophisticated routing features.

In addition to this, it comes in an ultra-compact form, meaning it is ready to fit anywhere you want it to. 

Another alternative is to use 24V passive PoE input. The passthrough option is available to support an individual airMAX device.  

Features of Ubiquiti Networks EdgeRouter

Great Price to Performace Value 

  • The Ubiquiti Networks EdgeRouter has lived up to its reputation by offering a great combination of value and performance. 

  • Certainly, with a price of just $59, it is a reliable option to consider when you are looking for something affordable without compromising on the service quality. 

Centralized Management

  • Now have complete control over your network by using Ubiquiti Network Management System.

  • The EdgeRouter comes equipped with UNMS that is not only a comprehensive controller but also offers an intuitive user-interface. 

  • Furthermore, the UNMS allows a single control plane to manage all the registered EdgeMAX devices across multiple sites.

Passive PoE Input 

  • An external adapter powers the EdgeRouter.

  • Another alternative is to use 24V passive PoE input. The passthrough option is available to support an individual airMAX device. 

Gigabit Connectivity and Much More!

  • The EdgeRouter offers up to 5 independent Gigabit ports. These are flexible and open to configuration for switching.

  • Precisely, this device includes an integrated Command-line interface which makes it convenient to access advanced features and functions. 

EdgeOS Software

  • The EdgeOS comes with robust features that include DHCP services, Ipv6 support, Firewall policies, and NAT rules. 

  • This operating system also works well with Network administration and monitoring tools.

  • Moreover, you will have static routes and support of routing protocols including BGP, OSPF, and RIP.

Configuration By CLI

  • You will, surely, get a quick and easy configuration with EdgeRouter.

  • The configuration feature by CLI lets you monitor all advanced features, provides direct access to standard Linux tools and easy use of shell commands.

Ubiquiti USG vs EdgeRouter: Final Verdict

We are sure, by now you would have a clear idea about the main similarities and differences between USG vs EdgeRouter. Let us wrap it for you for a quick overview!

USG is a better choice if you want to manage all the devices centrally from the same controller software. Another catch for USG is that it is super easy to configure to manage.

What about ER? It offers more control and flexibility while setting up. Furthermore, you will know at every step where you head with networking and security. So, what will your final choice be? Let us know in the comment section below!

Hey there, I am Amelia Rose, Online Tech Specialist with plenty of experience in Tech Products including router, speaker & more. I love solving problems. I make very good sushi. : )

Write A Comment